Astoria residents overwhelmingly oppose new high-rises near failed Innovation QNS site

Astoria locals are pushing back on plans for three high-rise buildings on Steinway Street.  Screenshot via Google Maps

By Ryan Schwach

Dozens of Astoria residents testified against three proposed housing developments on Tuesday night at a local community board meeting, with not one of them speaking in favor of the projects proposed near the site of the former plan to build Innovation QNS, a controversial neighborhood redevelopment that developers abandoned in recent years.

Of the 242 comments sent to the local Community Board 1, only one was in favor, according to Chair Evie Hantzopolous.

The three projects, all located on the far west end of Steinway Street, would be between nine and 17 stories and would bring a combined 457 new housing units to the corner of Astoria.

However, locals in the deeply progressive Western Queens community argued that the projects wouldn’t come with nearly enough affordable housing, and would only contribute to higher costs for current residents.

Hantzopolous told the Eagle on Wednesday that people were mobilized against the projects by “the imbalance of the kind of housing that's coming in, and the levels of affordability,” as well as by an affection for Steinway Street.

The argument has been made before in Western Queens, where locals say they are mostly in favor of more housing development, but worry that they will be priced out of the community.

The projects lie in the shadow of the area that was once the site for Innovation QNS, a $2 billion mega-project that promised to be a major development for the community but was ultimately abandoned by its developers.

On Tuesday, dozens of locals in Astoria testified against the three projects at 34-14, 22 and 34-49 Steinway St.

“There is just so much luxury development in Astoria already, and there are very few opportunities that we have where we actually have community input, and we can make sure that luxury development does not continue to displace our neighbors,” Rana Abdelhamid, a community leader who recently ran for the State Assembly, testified. “I think it's really, really important that we stand against anything that would further activate the housing crisis here in New York.”

Many locals who spoke said they believe they wouldn’t be able to afford to live in buildings like the ones pitched by developers.

“We don't need this,” a Steinway resident named William said. “I'm working class and I barely can afford what I'm doing. So, if this proposal was about affordable housing, I would be for it. But it's not. We need affordable housing.”

The proposed developments also come as Steinway Street has seen a scourge of small businesses closing due to high costs.

“You go up and down Steinway Street, the small businesses that were owned by families are gone, and every time I talk to them, they tell me that the landlord comes in and jacks up the rent, doubles up the rent,” Dannelly Rodriguez, an Astoria resident and housing attorney, said. “That's what we can expect.”

These arguments are not new for Western Queens.

Rana Abdelhamid, a community member and former Assembly candidate, was one of dozens of Astoria residents who testified against a trio of housing developments on Tuesday.  Screenshot via Queens Community Board 1

Nearly identical arguments came up before CB1 and its neighbor Community Board 2 when the city’s OneLIC neighborhood redevelopment plan was moving through the rezoning process last year, and when Innovation QNS was in the pipeline for the same area.

Hantzopoulos said that the pushback this time around is also a response to previous housing fights, and the lack of affordability that seemingly came with them.

“We're seeing some of the construction that started on the former Innovation QNS site, and there was a promise of 45 percent affordable housing, and no one can really explain whether that's happening or not,” she said. “There were things that were promised both by the city and by the developers when the rezoning was kind of making its way through the process, and so now that team disbanded, what happens to those promises?”

Community Board 1 now has less time than it once did to review the project under new city land use procedures that were passed in 2024.

The board’s land use committee is expected to meet and vote on Dec. 2 before the full board vote later in the month. The community board can only issue a recommendation in favor or against the projects.