Judge rejects Eric Ulrich’s bid to dismiss bribery case
/Former Queens City Councilmember Eric Ulrich attempted to get the charges against him dismissed during trial on Wednesday, Nov. 18, 2026. AP file photo by Mary Altaffer
By Noah Powelson
Former Queens City Councilmember and Buildings Commissioner Eric Ulrich tried and failed to get the bribery charges against him dismissed after prosecutors completed their criminal case on Wednesday.
The Manhattan district attorney’s office rested its case against Ulrich on Wednesday after presenting a trove of evidence this past month – including recorded phone calls, police surveillance and financial records – that prosecutors say prove the former city councilmember was taking bribes from local business owners in exchange for favors.
In response, both Ulrich and his co-defendant, Michael Mazzio, moved to have the bribery and conspiracy charges against them dismissed on Wednesday.
David Cohen – Ulrich’s attorney – argued that none of the recorded phone calls, text messages or surveilled meetings Ulrich had with various Queens businessmen demonstrated that he ever made an agreement to perform favors for payment. While there was no dispute that Ulrich was paid thousands of dollars by Mazzio and others while he worked for Mayor Eric Adams, Cohen said that alone did not prove they were bribes.
Cohen argued the DA’s office failed to show evidence that Ulrich believed he was expected to perform tasks in exchange for the payments, and that bribery could only be proven if prosecutors established that Ulrich was aware of and had agreed to such arrangements.
“We've heard nothing from the witnesses testifying, nor reasonable inference, that Mr. Ulrich was in the mindset he was expected to do something,” Cohen said.
Mazzio’s attorneys made similar arguments, claiming no evidence showed Mazzio explicitly offered money in return for Ulrich’s help. Mazzio is accused of giving Ulrich at least $10,000 in Mets season tickets in exchange for Ulrich’s help with licensing issues involving Mazzio’s company – Mike’s Heavy Duty Towing.
Assistant District Attorney Guy Tardanico, who is leading the city’s case against Ulrich, said that his office had met its burden to show the case had legs.
Tardanico argued they did not need evidence of a written or verbal agreement to prove Ulrich took bribes, and that a defendant’s conduct over time could also establish that bribes were taken. He also argued that the extensive records of payments Ulrich received after helping Mazzio and others who had business with the city were more than sufficient to establish the charges.
Manhattan Supreme Court Justice Daniel Conviser dismissed the motion, ruling that prosecutors had met their burden to show the evidence was legally sufficient to pursue the charges.
After the judge’s ruling, Mazzio also took the stand and testified about litigation his towing company faced from the then-Department of Consumer Affairs, as well as his relationship with Ulrich.
Ulrich’s case is expected to continue through the week.
Conviser, who will ultimately issue a verdict in the non-jury trial, said that he would likely rule in the case a few days after the defense rests.
