Prosecutorial watchdog to ask judge to toss Queens DA’s attempt to halt investigation

The Commission on Prosecutorial Conduct plans to ask a Queens judge to throw out a lawsuit challenging its authority and existence brought by the Queens district attorney’s office. Eagle file photo by Jacob Kaye

By Jacob Kaye

The state’s Commission on Prosecutorial Conduct is preparing to ask a judge to toss a lawsuit from the Queens district attorney’s office that claims that the recently created watchdog group is illegally investigating a notorious wrongful conviction case in Queens – and that the commission should be permanently disbanded.

The New York State Commission on Prosecutorial Conduct said in a letter to Queens Supreme Court Justice Joseph Esposito on Tuesday that it plans to file a motion to dismiss the DA’s lawsuit, which claims the commission is unconstitutional, according to court records.

Ross Firsenbaum, an attorney at WilmerHale who is representing the commission in the case, said in the letter that the DA’s suit against the commission – which has only recently begun investigating complaints about prosecutorial misconduct – has a number of defects.

The attorney claimed that Queens District Attorney Melinda Katz’s office brought the case in the wrong court and that it didn’t work hard enough to resolve the dispute with the commission before filing the lawsuit. He also said that Katz’s suit – which centers around the idea that the commission does not have the legal authority to carry out its mission – is “wrong on the merits.”

The commission’s impending motion comes around two weeks after Katz’s office sued the commission in an effort to block it from investigating the wrongful convictions of George Bell, Rohan Bolt and Gary Johnson, three men who spent a combined 72 years in prison for a double murder they did not commit. After Bell, Bolt and Johnson’s convictions were overturned in 2021, a Queens judge accused the two prosecutors in the 1996 case of purposefully hiding evidence that suggested someone else was behind the murders. Beyond the judicial scolding, neither Brad Leventhal nor Charles Testagrossa, the former Queens prosecutors on the case, has been formally found to have committed any wrongdoing.

The DA’s lawsuit, which was first reported by the Eagle and is now under seal, claims that the commission doesn’t have the authority to investigate prosecutors who no longer are employed by a district attorney or to unseal the Queens case files it sought from the DA’s office through a number of subpoenas sent over the summer. It also more broadly alleges that the 2021 law that created the commission is unconstitutional.

The lawsuit could have major implications for the commission. The CPC was found to be unconstitutional by a judge in 2020, prompting state lawmakers to rework the law and relaunch the commission in 2021. The CPC sat unstaffed for several years as Governor Kathy Hochul slowwalked her appointments to the commission. Last year, after receiving the required number of commissioners and staff, it made its first and only ruling to date – the censure of former Monroe County District Attorney Sandra Doorley, who used her title as the Western New York county’s top cop to try to get out of a speeding ticket.

The commission, which is now looking into the more than 450 complaints it has received in the past two years, including the complaints against Leventhal and Testagrossa, is operating legally, Firsenbaum said in his letter.

The attorney claimed the law creating the commission allows it to investigate both current and former prosecutors and that it doesn’t unlawfully intrude upon the work of the Appellate Division’s grievance committee, which currently investigates prosecutorial and attorney misconduct and, unlike the commission, has the power to hand down discipline when it finds wrongdoing. Under the 2021 law, the CPC and the Appellate Division work hand-in-hand, with the commission issuing recommendations to the courts, which can either accept or reject them, according to Firsenbaum.

The letter also claims that the commission has the legal right to seek to have courts unseal cases that are under investigation.

“The CPC’s legal mandate would be impossible to fulfill without access to the records sought by the subpoenas,” Firsenbaum wrote. “The legislature charged the CPC with reviewing and investigating the conduct of prosecutors and making recommendations to the Appellate Division as to whether such conduct violates applicable laws and rules of conduct.”

“The QCDA’s apparent position that none of its records are obtainable would make it impossible for the CPC to get the very evidence necessary to determine the scope of the [evidence sharing] violations that occurred: evidence of what the QCDA’s prosecutors knew and did (or did not do) with the information they had,” he added.

But beyond the CPC’s rejection of the claims made by the DA in her suit, Firsenbaum said Katz’s legal action had a number of fatal flaws.

The attorney said that the case should have been filed in Manhattan, the borough where the CPC’s offices are located and from where the subpoenas Katz’s office is fighting were sent.

Firsenbaum also argued that the DA didn’t follow the rules of the court when it allegedly failed to “make good-faith efforts to resolve all of the issues it raises” before filing the lawsuit.

According to the letter, the CPC also plans to argue that Esposito was wrong to temporarily halt the CPC’s effort to obtain the records it sought in its subpoenas, as outlined in a Nov. 9 order that was not uploaded to the case’s docket until Nov. 17.

In order to be granted a temporary restraining order like the one awarded to the DA’s office, a court user is required to establish by clear and convincing evidence that they would suffer irreparable injury if the order is not granted, that they would eventually succeed on the merits of their case and that the public interest favors the order. Firsenbaum said in his letter that the DA “has not, and cannot, meet this burden.”

Neither the CPC nor the Queens DA’s office responded to a request for comment from the Eagle on Wednesday.