Immigration advocates push Hochul for more legal aid for children

Advocates are calling on Governor Kathy Hochul to allocate $200 million toward immigration legal services in her upcoming executive budget. File photo by Susan Watts/Office of Governor Kathy Hochul

By Jacob Kaye

A coalition of legal service providers is calling on the governor for a $200 million boost in state funding for immigration legal services, including $20 million for legal services for immigrant children, which have seen a spike in demand amid the Trump administration’s immigration crackdown.

The Immigrant Children Advocates’ Relief Effort, a coalition that includes Catholic Charities Community Services, Kids in Need of Defense, The Legal Aid Society, The Door, and Safe Passage Project, said in an open letter to the governor that the state should send more money to legal and social services for immigrants, including $20 million specifically dedicated to legal representation for immigrant children.

The request comes after the Trump administration allowed a $356 million-a-year contract for legal services for children to expire, leaving around 1,300 immigrant children in New York and another 20,000 nationwide without federally funded legal services.

Though Hochul allocated $7.25 million to patch up the loss of the federal legal services contract earlier this year, ICARE called on her to do more to expand services for immigrants and immigrant children.

“Children should not be expected to defend themselves against deportation without a lawyer, facing a trained government attorney in one of the most complex areas of law,” Sierra Kraft, executive director of ICARE Coalition, said in a statement. “Governor Hochul’s emergency investment was a critical lifeline, but we cannot rely on emergency funding to sustain a system that children depend on for their safety and future.”

The coalition demanded $90 million to sustain existing legal and social services programs, $60 million to address new deportation defense needs and $50 million to allow legal providers to hire more attorneys and staff. Of those funds, ICARE called for $20 million to be allocated for legal representation for immigrant youth.

ICARE joined a number of other nonprofits and advocates in making the broader request for $200 million in funding, including the Vera Institute of Justice and the New York Immigration Coalition.

The coalition said that additional funding for legal representation for children would make a big difference in the outcome of many cases. Children without an attorney have around a 15 percent chance of winning their deportation case, while those who have a lawyer have around a 90 percent chance of winning their case, according to ICARE.

“No child should be forced to stand alone in immigration court, facing a trained government attorney without anyone to defend their rights,” Ting Poon, the supervising attorney with the Immigrant Youth Project at The Legal Aid Society, said in a statement. “Every day, legal service providers see firsthand how a shortage of qualified attorneys leaves vulnerable children at risk of deportation, even when they may be eligible for protection under the law.”

The group also called on the legislature to pass and the governor to sign a pair of bills that they say would bolster the state’s ability to provide legal services to immigrants.

The Access to Representation Act would establish a statewide right to counsel for low-income immigrants facing deportation. The bill would likely need to be passed alongside the Building Up Immigrant Legal Defense Act, which would require the state to expand the immigration legal services workforce through fellowships, recruitment, training and mentorship.

In a statement, a spokesperson for the governor said Hochul’s “top priority is keeping our families safe, which includes protecting our youngest New Yorkers from the fear, trauma and disruption caused by ICE overreach.”

“The Governor has committed millions of dollars to provide legal services for vulnerable immigrant children and is committed to working with the legislature to keep New Yorkers safe,” the spokesperson said. “Governor Hochul will review all legislation that passes both houses of the state legislature and details of the governor's Executive Budget Proposal will be released in January.”