Mamdani makes his first judicial appointments

Mayor Zohran Mamdani appointed the first judges of his tenure on Monday, 10 months after he named Queens attorney Ali Najmi (left) to overhaul the city’s process for naming judges. File photo by Michael Appleton/Mayoral Photography Office

By Ryan Schwach

Mayor Zohran Mamdani made the first judicial appointments of his mayoral tenure on Monday, naming 10 new judges to the bench and reappointing six others.

Many of the new jurists come from a background in public defense, fulfilling an earlier promise to diversify the legal experiences of the city’s judiciary.

Of the new appointments, split between Criminal and Family Courts, six of the judges previously worked as public defenders. Two of the newly appointed Criminal Court judges are former assistant district attorneys in Queens.

The appointments and reappointments come after a complicated year for the Mayor’s Advisory Committee on the Judiciary.

In January, Mamdani named Queens attorney Ali Najmi, a close ally of the mayor, to chair the committee and tasked him with overhauling how the city appoints new judges. Since then, the city has renewed its relationship with the New York City Bar Association to vet judges and changed the guidelines for reviewing candidates.

The administration also received criticism from Jewish groups after not naming any Jewish members to the 18-member committee appointed in August. Last month, Douglas Keith – who is Jewish – was made the executive director of the committee.

“MACJ worked hard to identify and recommend highly qualified candidates from a diverse pool of attorneys,” Najmi said in a statement. “New Yorkers deserve a fair and effective court system, and the Mayor’s appointments today reflect the immense responsibility and opportunity City Hall has to ensure the judiciary lives up to our values.”

Mamdani said the 10 new judges and six reappointed judges reflect the administration’s “commitment to a judiciary that treats every New Yorker fairly.”

“The decisions made in our courts can change the course of a New Yorker’s life,” he said. “That is why the people entrusted with serving on the bench must bring the highest standards of fairness, integrity and accountability to their work.”

Criminal Court appointees

The mayor appointed five new jurists to Criminal Court, three of whom have public defense backgrounds and two of whom worked in the Queens DA’s office.

Hana Kim has served in the Queens district attorney’s office for more than 15 years. She worked in the Felony Trial Bureau and Narcotics Trial Bureau and has held several leadership positions. She is currently the bureau chief of the Frauds Bureau.

Melissa Medilien also worked for six years as a Queens ADA in the Criminal Court Bureau, Rider Program, Narcotics Trial Bureau and Domestic Violence Bureau. She most recently served as an associate counsel at the Metropolitan Transportation Authority.

Molly Gallivan currently works as a senior homicide attorney at Brooklyn Defender Services, and previously spent five years at the Legal Aid Society’s Criminal Defense Practice.

William Kendall is currently the supervising attorney in the Criminal Defense Practice at the Neighborhood Defender Service of Harlem.

Alexis Flyer currently works as a principal court attorney in Kings County Supreme Court, but she also worked in the Legal Aid Society’s Criminal Defense Practice for nine years after graduating law school.

Family Court appointees

Of the five new judges appointed to Family Court, three come from a public defense background.

Mary Cheng began her career in Maryland as a staff attorney in the family law unit of the Maryland Legal Aid Bureau. Upon moving to New York, she joined the Children’s Law Center, where she was promoted to senior staff attorney and eventually co-director. She also established a solo practice as an 18-B attorney. She currently works as a court attorney and as a court attorney referee in Kings County.

Several of the judges appointed by Mayor Zohran Mamdani on Monday come from a public defense, and two of them worked at Brooklyn Defender Services. Eagle file photo by Ryan Schwach

Brian Holbrook is a senior attorney for law and appeals at Brooklyn Defender Services’ Family Defense Practice. Before joining BDS, he clerked for a judge on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 10th Circuit.

Beth Krause is a supervising attorney at the Legal Aid Society’s Immigration Law Unit and also worked as an 18-B attorney.

Deana Tietjen is currently the deputy executive director at the Children’s Law Center. She also spent 20 years in private practice representing litigants and social service agencies in New York City Family Court.

Danielle Rodriguez comes from a court background, having served as a court attorney-referee in New York City Family Court for nearly a decade. She most recently worked in Richmond County Family Court. She also previously worked in Manhattan Family Court.

Reappointments

Mamdani also reappointed six judges, two of whom have been serving in Queens.

Judge Toni Cimino has been an acting justice of the Supreme Court, Queens County since 2019. She began her career as a criminal defense attorney, practicing for seven years before joining the Unified Court System in 1999. She was first appointed to the bench in 2016.

Judge Jennifer Saint-Preux has been serving as a Criminal Court judge in Queens since last year, County. Prior to that, she spent three years at the Legal Aid Society before joining the Queens court system. She is also a founding member of the Queens Criminal Court Bar Association.

Of the other four reappointed judges, two have been working in Manhattan and two have been working in the Bronx.

Judge Tamiko Amaker is currently the administrative judge of New York City Criminal Court. She began her legal career as an assistant district attorney in the Bronx District Attorney’s Office, where she worked in the Domestic Violence and Child Abuse and Sex Crimes Bureau. She was first appointed to the bench by Mayor Michael Bloomberg and was reappointed by Mayor Bill de Blasio in 2017.

Judge Valentina Morales is a Criminal Court judge in New York County, assigned to Criminal and Supreme Court. She began her career as a public defender at the Neighborhood Defender Service of Harlem, Mayor Bill de Blasio appointed her to the bench in 2021.

Judge Joseph Sorrentino is a Criminal Court judge in the Bronx. He previously served in the Appellate Division, Second Department, as principal law clerk to Judge L. Priscilla Hall before being promoted to chief appellate court attorney. He was appointed to the bench in 2024 by Mayor Eric Adams.

Judge Juanita E. Wing serves as a Family Court judge in Bronx County. She began her career as a staff attorney at the Administration for Children’s Services before serving as a family law attorney at District Council 37. She also worked as an 18-B attorney before she was appointed to the bench in 2024.