Judicial watchdog calls on governor to reappoint Rivera to Court of Appeals
/Over 100 organizations called on Governor Kathy Hochul to reappoint Senior Associate Justice Jenny Rivera to the Court of Appeals. Photo via the Unified Court System
By Noah Powelson
A judicial watchdog group known for pressuring the state to deny recertification to judges is instead calling on the governor to reappoint the only former public defender currently sitting on the state’s highest court.
The Center for Community Alternatives and 115 advocacy groups sent Governor Kathy Hochul an open letter on Friday demanding that she reappoint Senior Associate Justice Jenny Rivera to the Court of Appeals when her term expires on Feb. 10, 2027. Rivera is still eligible for another term, but she’s competing for the seat with other prospective lower court judges and attorneys who could dramatically shift the court’s dynamic if Hochul decides to go with someone else.
The coalition said on Friday that Rivera has regularly been the deciding vote for cases that strengthen tenants’ rights, access to justice and due process protections. They said Hochul should either reappoint her or find a replacement with similar history representing New Yorkers against the government.
“Every nomination to the court matters, and the nomination you will make soon is especially
consequential, given the current legal and political climate in the country and in New York,” the letter to Hochul reads. “The progress that your appointments to the Court of Appeals have helped make possible must be a foundation for further advances, not a high-water mark from which the court retreats.”
Under state law, Hochul has to appoint someone from a list of candidates vetted by the Commission on Judicial Nomination. The application window for the seat closed in August, and Hochul’s office said she wouldn’t weigh in on the decision until the commission provides the list.
“The Commission on Judicial Nomination is currently reviewing applicants,” a spokesperson for the governor’s office said in response to an Eagle inquiry. “This administration looks forward to reviewing their suggested nominees in the near future."
Rivera is the only member of the seven-person judicial panel that has a background in public defense and human rights advocacy, and she has stood out as a progressive judge who’s willing to dissent against a court heavily represented by former prosecutors.
According to the platform Decoded, which publishes data analysis of the decisions judges make, Rivera tends to vote in favor of extending deadlines for civil claims and expanding due process protections more often than her peers on the top bench.
While CCA is trying to make sure a judge keeps her job, the group has led coalitions to do the opposite in the past.
In 2024, CCA campaigned against Judge Vincent Del Giudice of Brooklyn and Judge William Boller in Buffalo, who both announced they would retire instead of seeking recertification following CCA’s advocacy. That same year, CCA also called on the government to deny recertification to Bronx Judge Ralph Fabrizio, who had received numerous complaints from attorneys over alleged volatile outbursts during court proceedings.
CCA also led an unsuccessful attempt to stop Queens Supreme Court Justice Michael Aloise from being recertified in 2025.
Most recently, CCA called on the Office of Court Administration to deny the recertification of Supreme Court Justices Mario Mattei, Timothy Mazzei, Thomas Moran and Laura Ward, claiming the four judges made extensive errors during their time on the bench.
But CCA’s most impactful campaign was leading a coalition of criminal justice groups to prevent the nomination of Hector LaSalle as New York’s next chief judge in 2023.
LaSalle, who serves as the presiding justice of the Appellate Division, Second Judicial Department, was Hochul’s first choice to lead the Court of Appeals in 2023. The nomination received major pushback from progressive lawmakers, criminal justice organizations and others who were concerned LaSalle would continue to run a conservative Court of Appeals in the same vein as former Chief Judge Janet DiFiore.
The campaign ultimately worked, and the state Senate rejected LaSalle, the first time it had ever shot down a governor’s nomination to lead the Court of Appeals. Hochul then nominated Rowan Wilson, a CCA favorite, to serve as chief judge.
The coalition said on Friday that Wilson’s elevation was a step in the right direction toward reforming the court, but that it still needs jurists with diverse backgrounds to ensure the rights of all New Yorkers in all matters are protected.
Peter Martin, CCA’s director of Judicial Accountability, said the Court of Appeals plays a critical role in protecting New Yorkers from increased federal overreach. Martin said the Court of Appeals had a habit of “simply mirroring” the federal Constitution, and the state’s top court needed judges who could provide protections independent of the federal government.
“As the U.S. Supreme Court chips away at federal protections, New Yorkers are counting on our highest court to enforce the rights we have under state law,” Martin said in a statement. “A jurist’s experiences shape the decisions they make and the outcomes that New Yorkers must live with.”
“Experience representing people up against powerful interests, whether those are landlords,
corporations, or the state, is still too rare on New York’s highest court,” Martin added.
Even if Rivera is ultimately reappointed, she will reach the state’s mandatory retirement age in 2032 when she turns 70.
After Hochul decides what to do with Rivera’s seat, it won’t be too long before the process begins all over again. Three additional seats on the bench are expected to become vacant in 2029 and 2030.
